Best wood floor acoustics

Q: I am about do up my 14*11 penthouse room, and I want a wooden floor. I am definitely not going for a laminate. Should I go for softwood or hardwood, and how should I lay it? Considering I am a musician, it would be nice if it helps in the acoustics of the room. Which species has the best wood floor acoustics? Also, what are your thoughts on deodar cedar?

A: I’m not an expert on acoustics and don’t know how soft or hard wood affects that. I do know that concrete buildings generally require a sound absorbing barrier under a wood or engineered floor. That could be cork or a synthetic material. Keep in mind, the softer the wood, the easier it will dent.

Note from webmaster: Below are some related links I’ve digged up.

“My experience has been that wood flooring increases volume…” This forum has a thread on the issue in relation to various flooring effects on acoustics:

“Hardwood is better than carpet for acoustics…” a similar thread only in relation to hardwood:

“Wood and acoustics in buildings” and “Wood in concert halls” are some of the topics covered in this article:

Here is an article entitled “Sound Tranmission and Flooring Types”:

And this post hints at the complexity of the issue not just by species, but subspecies:

Good luck!