Ok, these sample boards I’ve been working on. I’m trying to show the difference in appearance between oil modified polyurethane and water borne urethane.
The samples are on steamed walnut (that is the sample with the consistent colouration), unsteamed walnut, quarter sawn white oak and plain sawn red oak. On the white oak I’ve also stained 2 sections golden brown and dark oak. One half has had one coat of water borne applied but I haven’t coated the other stained half with oil modified yet.
Which do you like most? The oil modified Primero went on smooth as glass, but I have to fight with the water borne. The water borne is significantly lighter in all cases. Especially on the red oak it looks ‘sterile’. After all these years, I’m still not a fan of water borne. There are versions of this finish which amber and maybe that would help to enhance the appearance of the wood. The only occasion I can think of when a water borne, non ambering must be used is for pastel stain colours such as white. I’m not yet convinced of the water borne coatings being as long lasting as oil based regardless of the ‘taber’ test which have been done. How does the coating stand up in real world activity? For smoothness and depth of colour, I don’t think a high quality oil modified can be beat.
An oil based stain plus an oil based polyurethane varnish
Can I add an oil based stain to an oil based polyurethane varnish and apply over my pre-sanded maple floor? Will this technique avoid the problem of staining maple floors and ending up with a blotchy stain look? What is a better solution? I want to avoid the light contemporary…
Using an oil based polyurethane over Zinsser finish
Q: We have 150 year old red oak floors with several coats of Zinsser Target clear epoxy based finish on them. We have been unable to find the same product and are thinking of using an oil based polyurethane over the existing finish. Will it stick and not bubble or…
I inadvertently walked on newly applied oil based polyurethane
Q: I inadvertently walked on newly applied oil based polyurethane in stocking feet and walked on a recently cured flooring of the same poly and left footmarks. I need some advise on how to economically repair this. A: Apply painters tape around the edges of the entire boards affected. Lightly…
Oil based polyurethane finish looks "dimpled"
Q: We recently had our red oak floors refinished, using Min-wax Red Oak color, and we chose oil-based polyurethane. We contacted the refinishing company after the third coat of polyurethane was applied because we thought the semi-gloss sheen looked somewhat cloudy where the light hits it, but clear when standing…
Water-based or oil based polyurethane
We have a 70-year old house with beautiful pine floors desperately in need of refinishing. So far we've had 3 professionals in to give us estimates. We have 2 large dogs so of course, durability is our primary concern and we're aware that we need to trim and file their…
2 thoughts on “I don’t think a high quality oil modified polyurethane can be beat (photos of samples)”
In Missouri. What brand oil based do you prefer
I just stumbled across this – that unsteamed walnut is beautiful – who is your supplier? I have been trying to track down a good source in Canada.