Water vs Oil

by

Q: I read a couple of threads that suggested water based polyurethane for floors may not be the best idea. Should we reconsider an oil based polyurethane before we start?

A: You can use water based finish for floors if so indicated on the label. The higher end finishes that flooring contractors use will not be purchased at Home Depot. For the home owner, an oil based finish if far easier to use, and will give you better protection, in my opinion. There are many good finishes on the market. I like the Circa 1850 Bowling Alley polyurethane.

Related Questions

  • Adding oil over water based finish?

    I recently had my oak floors refinished with water based poly. I would rather have had Oil but because of time constraints at that time I opted for the water. I want to put a couple of coats of oil on top. Can I just rough up the floor and…

  • Oil or water to match

    We just had the floors redone using an oil based polyurethane and I'm trying to get the stairs to match. The problem is the stairs were originally done with a water based polyurethane. Do I need to completely sand down the floors or can I apply the oil based polyurethane…

  • Water-based or oil based polyurethane

    We have a 70-year old house with beautiful pine floors desperately in need of refinishing. So far we've had 3 professionals in to give us estimates. We have 2 large dogs so of course, durability is our primary concern and we're aware that we need to trim and file their…

  • Hardwax oil finish

    Are you familiar with O*** P**** oil? How does it compare to Waterlox? I really like the look and benefits (easily repairable) of a hardwax oil finish. It seems technology has made even this type of floor low maintenance.

  • Water or oil based finish

    I am getting a lot of different opinions on which is a better method to refinish my wood floor, water or oil based finish?

  • Water based finish buff/coat over oil based?

    I have a floor on which a customer put 3 oil based coats. The customer wants to know if I can buff and coat the floor with a water based finish. Is this okay to do? Will it dry right?